Jack Palance

Paul 'Poppy' Davitch

Allan Van Praagh

Allan Van Praagh

Narrator (voice)

Jake Jennings (segment "Bitter Harvest")

John Witting

(archive footage)

Long John Silver

Ebenezer Scrooge

Beelzebub

Bob Greiser

Host

Self

Self (archive footage)

Self

Bartle Bone

Lord Rothbart (voice)

Self (archive footage)

Duke Page

Dr. Jeremy Wheaton (segment "Where the Dead Are")

Jake Stone

Mercy

Self - Guest

Host / Self - Judge Roy Bean

Executive Producer

Travis

Passage Narrator (voice)

Overstreet